I am INTJ and Enneagram 8, and I score highly disagreeable on the Big Five. Most personality tests are noise for most people, but for me, for the members of Tournament Male and for the bitcoiners I spend time with, they land with uncomfortable accuracy. Many of us are some variation of the 8, the 5 and the INTJ, or close cousins of them. I have no doubt there is a biological piece to how men like us find our way to the same ideas and the same technology.
That temperament is a strength when you are building your own life. It is a liability almost everywhere else.
The cost of always disagreeing
I am forty, one of the older bitcoiners, and I have played out disagreeableness longer than most. After 2016 and the Trump years, the amount of open disagreement in my life kept me in constant strife with nearly everyone around me. I had started to drift away from it even then.
Then 2020 arrived. Once covid kicked off, the failure of the disagreeable strategy became impossible to ignore. No one ever changes through disagreement. When I looked honestly at why I kept doing it, I had to admit it was mostly an unconscious compulsion to express myself, not a method that moved anyone.
How I sounded to other people
The idea of becoming outwardly agreeable had been building in me for a long time. A friend of mine studies NLP techniques, and he kept telling me the same thing: I spoke in a grating way. The way I put things made people defend themselves before they had even heard the point.
That is the trap for a dominant personality. You can be right on the substance and still guarantee the other man digs in, because you have made the conversation about winning.
Dominance as a weakness
After covid and the endless conflict it brought, I came to see my dominant propensity as a weakness, out of both necessity and philosophy. It is useful for forming my own plans. It is horrific for social cohesion, and a man who cannot keep his allies cannot build much with them.
Adaptive, subversive agreeableness
Since then I have practised what I call adaptive, subversive agreeableness. I rarely end up in conflict now. Conversations run far longer, and they happen from a place of relaxed candour instead of tension.
None of this means I assume I am always right. Those longer conversations are often illuminating, because one of my skills is pulling insight out of whatever is being discussed. Every viewpoint carries some kernel of truth, and agreeableness buys me the time to dig it out.
The days the old energy comes back
There are still days when the disagreeable energy runs strong. Those are the days I have to remember the folly of disagreement, and refuse to make enemies of men who would otherwise stand with me.
If you are in the 8, 5 and INTJ club, or one of its variants, I hope this journey is useful to you. The full story is in the video above.